noreply66 wrote:
The All-American Boy-Bill Parsons-1959-#2
M&L--Bill Parsons
The singer on this song was actually Bobby Bare.Fraternity Records released the song,mistakenly attributing it to Parsons.
Noreply, I'd heard the story for years that Bill Parsons was a pseudonym used by Bare. After seeing your post, I went to work to find the straight skinny, and I believe this is the correct .
Bare had a longtime friend, Bill Parsons, from Coalton OH, who'd met a man named Orville Lunsford. Parsons was a little older than Bare, and had just recently completer a tour of military service. He and Lunsford had written "All-American Boy" Parsons already had a recording session set up to do "rubber Dolly", a rock song, and needed a song for the flip side. He believed the drawling Bare could do "Boy" better than he could himself & so asked Bare to sing "Boy" at the session, and he did. Shortly afterwards, Bare entered the army & was unaware of what happened next for nearly 2 years.
Fraternity records purchased the master recordings from the recording studio, King Records of Cincy, and published the record, but Fraternity accidentally listed Parsons as the artist of both sides. Trouble began shortly after "Boy" unexpectedly became a monster hit, crashing its way through the Elvis-dominated Top 40.
Parsons & Lunsford accused Harry Carlson, Fraternity's owner, of cheating them of royalties, while Carlson argued it was BARE who'd performed the hit. Parsons countered that for every copy of "Boy" sold, a copy of"Rubber Dolly" had sold also.(That's why we seldom saw different artists on each side of a record.)
To keep a long story short, Bare, Parsons, Lunsford, & Carlson each testified in 1960 before the Congressional Subcommittee investigating Payola. There, the whole mess was laid "bare", and an amicable agreement was reached out of court. Parsons couldn't hit the charts again, & left the music business in 1961. Whenever asked, he always credits Bare with doing "Boy". Lunsford never did anything else in music that I know of.
Bare always credits Parsons & Lunsford for writing "Boy" & that he sang it to help his friend Parsons at Parsons' request.
When Bare hit the big time again, under his own name, with
Detroit City in 1963, the "Boy" thingie was all-but-lost as Bare continued to crank out hit after hit. (I believe he did
Shame On Me before he did
Detroit City.)
This, far as I can find out, is the truth about the saga of the "All-American Boy".